More power with less copper
Why we need to reduce reactive power
In addition to useful, usable power, every electrical installation also has a power that is not effectively converted into heat, movement or light. We call this ineffective power or reactive power. Reactive power provides an extra load on cables, pipes and transformers. The network operator must transport this reactive power. At the same time, we get less useful energy from our contracted capacity.
What is reactive energy, how does it arise and how can we reduce reactive energy? You can read the answers to these questions in this white paper.
What is reactive power?
In electrical installations, only a part of the power is used efficiently. This capacity is also called the actual capacity. It is converted by machines and equipment into movement, light, cooling or heat. Part of the power is always lost due to, for example, magnetism in motors and transformers and capacitors in electronic equipment. This is called reactive power or ineffective power. This power is fed back and forth 50 times per second in a 50 Hz network and not used effectively.
The real power (the beer) and the reactive power (the foam) added together, we call the apparent power
The real power and the reactive power added together, we call the apparent power. The entire network (the main distributor, transformers and main connection) must be able to distribute this apparent power. We can best compare this with a beer glass. The useful capacity (the beer) is used effectively. The non-useful capacity (the foam) ensures an increase in the capacity to be transported. The electrical installation (the beer glass) must be able to distribute useful and non-useful power. If the reactive power increases, the installation can become overloaded (the beer glass overflows).
The Power Factor
We call the ratio between the actual power and the apparent power the power factor. This is the factor that indicates how useful we use power. If the power factor is "1", 100% of the power is used effectively. In practice, this is often between 0.6 and 0.9. The use of a capacitor bank or an active filter can increase the power factor and even optimize it to "1".
What types of reactive power are there?
Inductive reactive power
Motors, transformers and control gears are inductive loads. With inductive loads, a power is required for magnetizing coils. This power is called the inductive reactive power. We call the vector sum of the real power (P) and the inductive reactive power (Q1) the apparent power (S1). In this example, the apparent power has an inductive character.
Capacitive reactive power
Capacitors in electronic equipment and long cables are capacitive loads. With capacitive loads, power is needed to charge this capacity. This power is called capacitive reactive power. The vector sum of the actual power (P) and the capacitive reactive power (Q1) is called the apparent power (S1). In this example, the apparent power has a capacitive character.
The extent to which the energy is used for inductive and capacitive reactive power is indicated by cos-phi. Internationally this is called the displacement power factor (dPF). This is the ratio between the actual and apparent power of the fundamental component (50Hz component).
Harmonic reactive power
More and more non-linear loads are being applied in modern installations. Examples of this are, for example, rectifiers (laptop power supplies, servers) and inverters in modern UPS and frequency inverters. A characteristic of a non-linear load is that the used current is no longer sinusoidal. We also call the distortion of the current that results from this harmonic distortion.
The extra power that results from the harmonic distortion is what we call the harmonic reactive power (Qh). This reactive power is neither inductive nor capacitive. That is why we plot the harmonic reactive power on a third axis, the so-called z-axis. The vector sum of the real power (P) and the harmonic blind power (Qh) is - again - called the apparent power (S).
A combination of types of reactive power
Practice shows a combination of different types of reactive power. In the example below, harmonic reactive power occurs and inductive reactive power prevails.
Terms to remember:
Displacement Power Factor (dPF or cos-phi) is the ratio of the actual power in (kW) and apparent power of the fundamental 50Hz component. If no harmonics are present, the total Power Factor (PF) is equal to the displacement Power Factor (dPF).
The Power Factor (PF) is the ratio between the actual and apparent power under all circumstances.
Reactive power in practice
The table below summarizes what type of reactive power prevails in which type of installation. This table is indicative and gives an average of at least 250 practical measurements. If you want to know for sure what the behavior of your installation is, we recommend performing a power quality measurement (or having it performed). Read more about (temporary) power quality measurements.
|Inductive reactive power||Capacitive reactive power||Harmonic reactive power|
|Industry - conventional||▲▲▲||▲|
|Industry - modern||▲||▲||▲▲▲|
|Marine & Offshore||▲||▲||▲▲|
The general trend is that through the use of electronics and electronic drives:
- inductive reactive power decreases;
- capacitive reactive power increases;
- harmonic reactive power increases.
Adverse effects of reactive power
Fines and claims
A too high reactive power can lead to a fine from the network operator. Too much reactive power leads to extra burdensome flows and therefore to extra load for the network operator. With harmonic reactive power, the network operator can file a claim if limit values are exceeded.
We need to add the actual power (kW) and reactive power (kVar) together to arrive at the total power (kVA) that must be able to run through the installation. In comparison with the beer glass model, this means that we add the beer and foam together. To prevent flooding of the beer glass, a larger beer glass must be invested. In practice, a higher connection capacity at the network operator, more transformer capacity and a heavier installation will be required.
A higher energy bill due to extra losses
More reactive power also means more power through the installation. More current through the installation means higher losses due to the impedance (resistance) of the installation. We also call this the watt losses. This in turn ensures that more kWs are included (P = I2 * R). These losses, converted into a comparison with beer glass, mean that - no matter how strange it may sound - there is more beer in the glass that is not used effectively, but is absorbed by heat in, for example, cables and transformers.
Derating of transformers and generators
Harmonic reactive power ensures a smaller available capacity of transformers and generators. Due to the higher frequencies of the harmonics, additional copper and eddy current losses and extra losses are generated by inductive and capacitive couplings. Back to the comparison with the beer glass: due to harmonic currents, the beer glass cannot be completely filled.
Various publications - including the application guides of the IEE519 - publish derating curves. Based on these publications and our own measurement experiences, we use the following rough guideline for derating transformers and generators.
|% electronic load relative to total|| Derating transformator
Generator controls encounter problems with capacitive currents. The output voltage then becomes unstable. The capacitive reactive power must, in any case, be less than twenty percent of the nominal generator power. For a stable generator operation, however, we recommend avoiding the capacitive reactive power as a whole.
Reduce reactive power
So there is every reason to reduce unwanted reactive power. There are three basic solutions for reducing reactive power:
- Cos-phi bank (capacitor bank)
- Static VAR generator (electronic cos-phi improvement)
- Active dynamic filter / harmonic filter
With a Cos-phi bank / capacitor bank
The capacitor bank is the most well-known solution for reducing reactive power and has been used for decades. The capacitor bank is - as the name implies - a cabinet full of capacitors with which the reactive power for the coil is supplied. As a result, the reactive power for the capacitor bank has disappeared and a cos-phi of 1 is measured.
For example, if the load absorbs 50kVar of inductive reactive power, and we then put a capacitor bank with a capacity of 50kVar, the complete induction is canceled and the cos-phi becomes 1 through the transformer.
All the inductive reactive power is supplied by the capacitor bank. This relieves the main distributor, transformer and customer connection, creating extra power space.
Advantages of capacitor bank:
- Relatively cheap
- Simple technology
Disadvantages of capacitor bank:
- Relatively slow due to relay switching time
- Overloaded by harmonic currents
- Does not adapt to changes in the network
- An outdated capacitor can cause an unwanted upset harmonic
A capacitor bank cannot be used:
- in a network with capacitive capacity, with the risk of resonances and fire;
- in an installation with a lot of harmonic power, the capacitor is a short circuit at higher frequencies;
- in installations where connected equipment can change;
- with rapidly changing loads and dynamic processes.
With a Static VAR generator (SVG)
A static VAR generator (SVG) is a fast electronic and stepless reactive current compensation without capacitors. The SVG measures the inductive current  and injects a current that is phase-shifted with the voltage  such that the current for the filter  is neatly in phase with the voltage.
Working principle of a static VAR generator
SVG advantages over a capacitor bank:
- Compensate both inductive and capacitive reactive power
- Superfast response time (<20ms)
- Fast and stepless, which means that over- or under-compensation is not possible
- More compact, lower in weight
- Less energy loss
- Not overloadable and insensitive to resonance and interharmonics
Over- or under-compensation is not possible with a Static VAR Generator
Disadvantage Static VAR Generator (SVG):
- Higher purchase price than a capacitor bank
Typical areas of application of an SVG are:
- In installations with rapidly changing loads where a capacitor battery is too slow
- In capacitive networks where the emergency power generator does not turn up properly
- In installations with equal-load phases where more power space is required
With an Active Harmonic Filter (AHF)
An active harmonic filter (AHF) filters harmonic currents with an operating principle that is based on the principle of noise cancelling. The filter measures the current contamination  and injects a counter-current  that is of such a shape that the current for the filter  becomes nicely sinusoidal again. This compensates for all the harmonic reactive power. The harmonic filter is also capable of compensating both inductive and capacitive reactive power, with which such a filter can be used universally and is not overloaded.
Working principle of an active filter
All the harmonic reactive power is supplied by the active filter. This relieves the main distributor, transformer and customer connection, creating extra power space.
Advantages of an active harmonic filter:
- Compensate for both inductive, capacitive and harmonic reactive power
- Even more power space by limiting derating power transformer
- Super-fast response time (<5ms) and continuous adaptation to the load
- All power quality problems can be solved
- Fewer losses, lower footprint
- Not over-loadable and insensitive to resonance and interharmonic
Disadvantage of active harmonic filter:
- Higher purchase price than capacitor bank
In addition to reducing harmonic reactive power, an active filter is capable of tackling all power quality problems. A side effect of an active filter is to improve the voltage quality. In other words: an active filter ensures more stable business processes, longer life span of electronic equipment and much less unwanted outages. At the same time, this complies with international standards for voltage quality. This will prevent the warranties on equipment from being canceled. In addition, an active filter can eliminate an uneven load on the phases, which leads to extra power space and fewer watt losses in the installation.
Central or decentralized compensation?
The question is often asked whether central or decentralized compensation is required. The size of the required compensation capacities, the structure of the installation and the installation options on-site determine the best solution.
The total reactive power flows through the entire installation without compensation. The sub-distributors, main distributor, main protection and the transformer are charged with reactive power.
With decentralized compensation, the compensation system is placed with the consumers.
Advantage of decentralized compensation:
- The entire installation is relieved of the reactive current
Disadvantages of decentralized compensation:
- Higher purchase and maintenance costs than with central compensation
- Relatively high installation costs because the compensation system is placed at the sub-distributor
With central compensation, the compensation system is often placed on the main distributor of the installation (directly behind the transformer). The main protection, the transformer, and the main connection are thus relieved of the reactive power. The reactive power remains in the internal cabling and sub-distributors.
Benefits of central compensation:
- Lower purchase and maintenance costs
- Relatively low installation costs in the room where the low-voltage main distributor is located
- The most important installation components are relieved of reactive current
The disadvantage of central compensation:
- The sub-distributors and the cabling from and to the sub-distributors is still charged with the reactive current
The apparent power is the sum of the active power (effective power) and reactive power (ineffective power). Reactive power is not converted into useful energy and can consist of inductive, capacitive and harmonic reactive power or a combination of these. The use of electronics reduces inductive reactive power and increases harmonic and capacitive reactive power. As the reactive power increases, the apparent power increases and thus the required capacity of the installation. Harmonic reactive power also ensures a smaller available capacity due to the derating of transformers and generators.
Inductive reactive power can be reduced by applying a capacitor bank. With an active dynamic filter, all types of reactive power can be reduced and the derating of the transformer or generator is limited. This cuts the knife on two sides.
Continuous measurement and monitoring is necessary to determine the correct compensation system and to monitor it.
Reducing reactive power leads to:
- Less power through the installation, transformer and grid connection
- Fewer watt losses, so a lower energy bill
- A larger available transformer or generator capacity if an active filter is used
The compensation to be applied depends on the type of power that occurs in the installation.
|Type of power|| Inductive, Stable
||Inductive, Fast changing||Capacitive reactive power||Harmonic reactive power|
Reduction of reactive power in ten steps
Deliberately come to the right solution
Simply installing capacitor banks or active filters seems easy but is not cost-effective and can even be dangerous. Placing capacitor banks in installations with too many harmonics can lead to resonances due to the interaction of the harmonic currents and the capacitors in the reactive current compensation. In addition, it can lead to overloading of the capacitor bank with all its consequences. Placing an active filter if it is actually not necessary or if the intended effect is not forthcoming, is a waste of money.
That is why it is important to first perform a measurement - preferably for a longer period of time - with which the correct compensation technique and capacity can be determined. We always go through a ten-step plan to place a compensation system at fortop.
|Reduction of reactive power in ten steps|
|Step 1||Placing a permanent measurement or a temporary measurement|
|Step 2||Determining the correct compensation techniques based on measurement data|
|Step 3||Determine the correct compensation capacity based on measurement data|
|Step 4||Engineering, consultation with parties involved about the method of installation|
|Step 5||Possible guidance and supervision during installation of the filter system|
|Step 6||Commissioning the compensation system|
|Step 7||Validation measurement|
|Step 8||Prepare delivery report|
|Step 9||Permanent monitoring of the system|
|Step 10||Perform annual maintenance and advice on changes to the installation|
One point of contact for all parts
Measuring, monitoring, improvement, commissioning and maintenance
Power management is a continuous improvement process of measuring, monitoring and improving with the aim of saving energy, preventing failure and optimally utilizing the installation. Fortop has a team of technical specialists who can guide you through all these steps of power management. From the choice of the right meters at every level to the commissioning and maintenance of software and active compensation systems. We help you prepare and implement the ten-step plan.